HomeMy WebLinkAbout03/06/2000 � � �
Telecommunications Advisory Committee
City of Apple Valley
March 6, 2000
7:00 P.M. City Hall
Minutes
l. Call to Order
The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m. by Chairperson Bible.
Members Present: Rollin Bible, Jerry Brown, Dale Rodell, David Westbrook
Members Absent: John Magnusson, Scott Hugstad-Vaa
Others Present: Charles Grawe, Mark Moore, Denis LaComb, Ellen Martin, Ma�c
Thompson
2. Approval of Agenda
Mr. Bible asked for changes to the agenda. No changes were requested. The agenda was
approved as presented.
3. Approve Minutes
Mr. Westbrook moved, second by Mr. Brown, to approve the minutes of December 2,
1999. Motion passed unanimous.
Mr. Rodell moved, second by Mr. Westbrook, to approve the minutes of February 9,
2000. Motion passed unanimous.
4. Approve 1999 Annual Cable & Telecommunications Report
Mr. Grawe briefly reviewed the Annual Report. He noted that this year's report provides
a summary of the activities and costs associated with the franchise renewal and transfer
of ownership. He also noted that under the old franchise the City received one annual
payment for the previous year's franchise fees. Under the new agreement, the franchise
fees are paid on a quarterly basis. Thus, in 1999, the City received the entire payment of
1998 franchise fees and the first three-quarter's fees for 1999. Mr. Bible asked about the
PEG fees. Mr. Grawe said due to a clerical error, the City had not received its third and
fourth-quarter PEG fees. Ms. Martin said the fees were mailed during the first week of
March. Mr. Grawe said an accounting of the PEG fees would be added to the annual
report upon receipt of the fees. Ms. Martin distributed the cable company portion of the
report.
� � �
Mr. Westbrook moved, second by Mr. Brown, to approve the report as amended to show
an accounting for the PEG fees. Motion passed unanimous.
5. Nletricom Wireless Proposal
Mr. Grawe distributed a memo outlining staff concerns for a potential agreement. He
also distributed an article on the future of wireless data services providers. Mr. Bible
noted that there are three competing types of service being offered. He advised the
Committee to expect other providers to approach the City in the future. Mr. Grawe
briefly described the nine concerns outlined in the memo.
Mr. Rodell asked if the FCC regulations apply. Mr. Thompson said the FCC rules are
very strict and generally make the City's language superfluous. Mr. Thompson also
noted that if the system is not properly installed and maintained, it could cause
interference for other service providers. Mr. Thompson noted that 25 of the 75 cities
approached to date have signed the agreement. Some of the larger cities include
Roseville, New Hope, Crystal, Hopkins, Brooklyn Park, Brooklyn Center, Mounds View,
and Woodbury. Mr. Westbrook asked how many cities would need to sign to begin the
installation in the region. Mr. Thompson said he did not know for sure, but would guess
80 to 85 percent. He said all the cities seem satisfied with the compensation, but some
want to wordsmith the agreement. Mr. Westbrook asked if enough cities would agree in
time for early installation. Mr. Thompson said he believes many cities are warming to
the agreement as more cities sign. Mr. Brown asked when installation would occur. Mr.
Thompson said August is not likely anymore, but hopes that it would be this year. He
noted that the entire country is requesting hardware at the same time. Mr. Rodell asked if
the Cities of Minneapolis and St. Paul had signed the agreement. Mr. Thompson said
both are close to signing.
Mr. Westbrook moved, second by Mr. Bible, to recommend the City Council approve the
agreement, subject to the identified staff concerns being addressed to the satisfaction of
staff and the City Attorney. Motion passed unanimous.
6. 1 st Quarter Complaint Log
Mr. Grawe noted that the second complaint had been recently resolved.
7. Other
a. Mr. Grawe said Charter had notified the City of its intent to raise the basic rates
to $11.93. He said a special meeting would be necessary to meet the rate
regulation requirements. Mr. Bible requested a special meeting for April. Mr.
Grawe said he would send out a rate survey to other cities.
.,. � �
b. Ms. Martin said Charter is still investigating the reimbursement of legal fees for
the transfer of ownership. She said a new insurance form will be sent to the City
shortly and the public access equipment is being collected.
8. Adjourn
Mr. Rodell moved, second by Mr. Westbrook, to adjourn the meeting. Motion passed
unanimous. The meeting was adjourned at 7:55 p.m.