HomeMy WebLinkAbout02/11/1997
Telecommunications Advisory Committee
City of Apple Valley
February 11, 1997
7:00 P.M. City Hall
Minutes
1. Call to Order
The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m. by Chairperson Bible.
Members Present: Dale Rodell, Rollin Bible, David Westbrook, Scott Hugstad-Vaa,
John Magnusson
Members Absent: Jerry Brown
Others Present: Charles Grawe, Denis LaComb, Patsy Hoyt, Darin Helgeson,
Laura Rosario, Danielle Rosario, Ruben Rosario
2. Approval of Minutes of October 21, 1996
The minutes of October 21, 1996 were approved unanimous (motion by Mr. Rodell,
second by Mr. Westbrook).
3. Approval of Minutes of November 12, 1996 Public Hearing
The minutes of November 12, 1996 were approved unanimous (motion by Mr. Hugstad-
Vaa, second by Mr. Magnusson).
4. Franchise Renewal Update
Mr. Bible gave a brief update regarding the cable franchise renewal. He explained that the
City’s negotiating team met with representatives of Marcus Cable in December. He
explained that the Committee’s role has expanded beyond cable and that Marcus also
could provide services beyond cable television. The negotiating team expressed an interest
in working with Marcus on other telecommunications services beyond cable television.
Mr. Bible said that he had a subsequent telephone conference with several representatives
of Marcus and will meet on the week of March 24, 1997 to further discuss this issue.
Mr. Bible expressed his concern that the attorney’s for the City and for Marcus begin
work on the franchise document as soon as possible. Mr. Bible asked that both Marcus
and the City talk to their respective attorneys about expediting the renewal process. Mr.
Bible also mentioned that the needs assessment element has not been satisfied by the City
and that the November public hearing was not as successful as anticipated. Mr. Creighton
has emphasized that a needs assessment is important and has suggested a possible
consulting firm to conduct the assessment. Mr. Bible also requested that the City write
another article for the Chamber newsletter.
Mr. Grawe added that Marcus cable had offered to conduct the needs assessment for the
City. Mr. Grawe said that he had discussed this with Mr. Vose of Tom Creighton’s office
and Mr. Vose felt it was worth exploring. Mr. Grawe also said that the City staffs of
Apple Valley, Farmington, Lakeville, and Rosemount had been meeting to discuss joint
franchise renewal efforts. Mr. Grawe said that the Cities of Farmington and Rosemount
would be approaching the City of Apple Valley about participating in Apple Valley’s
franchise renewal process.
Mr. Helgeson said that Marcus also wants to move quickly in the renewal process. He
explained that dollars have been budgeted for rebuilds in 1997 and a quick renewal will
keep budgeted dollars from being reallocated to other systems. Mr. Helgeson explained
that the upgrade will be a fiber/coaxial cable hybrid. The current system has up to 45
amplifiers before reaching the end user. With the upgrade, fiber nodes will be installed,
decreasing the number of amplifiers to 4 or 5. The upgrade will increase speed, capability,
and reliability. He further stated that the exact number of channels to be provided has not
been set, although with compression technology, it is possible to receive 6-10 additional
channels for each existing channel. The upgrade will be activated by node location, so
activated areas will have different channel capacities and line ups.
5. Review of Complaint Log
The Committee reviewed the complaint log for the last quarter of 1996. Mr. Bible
expressed concern that the District Manager is often absent from the area. Ms. Hoyt
explained that the District Manager has many franchises in Wisconsin and that other local
staff are available.
6. Z-TV Letter
The Committee reviewed the letter from Susan Herman requesting that Marcus carry Z-
TV. There was brief discussion that additional channels may be made available as channel
compression allows.
7. Web Page Update
Charles Grawe reported that the Web Page construction is underway. The Committee
asked Charles to make a demonstration of the Page available to the Committee before it is
released. Charles mentioned that the joint City and Chamber Tourism Bureau may have
an interest in buying a few pages on the City’s site.
Mr. Rodell moved, second by Mr. Westbrook, that the City allow the Visitor’s Bureau to
purchase pages on the City’s site. Motion carried unanimous.
8. Univision Channel Discussion
Ms. Laura Rosario asked why the City is renewing the franchise with Marcus. Mr. Bible
explained the City’s role in the franchise renewal and the limitations imposed on the City
by federal law. Mr. Bible explained that the City could not force Marcus to carry a
particular cable channel. There was brief discussion about the profitability of carrying
Univision and why Univision is carried elsewhere in the Metro area. Mr. Bible urged Ms.
Rosario to help Marcus understand why carrying Univision is a good idea for Marcus
economically. Mr. Helgeson explained that by corporate agreements, the local Marcus
headend is legally obligated to add MSNBC and EYES ON PEOPLE as the next channels
when capacity is available. Mr. Bible asked if any channels will likely be dropped. Mr.
Helgeson said that the corporate office signs many agreements by which the local company
must operate and that it is very difficult to drop channels.
Mr. Westbrook moved, second by Mr. Magnusson, that the Committee recommend to
Marcus Cable that Univision be added as soon as possible. Motion carried unanimous.
9. Adjourn
The meeting was adjourned at 8:00 P.M..