HomeMy WebLinkAbout2023-12-20 Regular Meeting MinutesCITY OF APPLE VALLEY
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES
December 20, 2023
1. CALL TO ORDER
The City of Apple Valley Planning Commission Meeting was called to order by Chair Kurtz
at 7:00 p.m.
Members Present: Jodi Kurtz, David Schindler, Paul Scanlan, and Jeff Prewitt
Member(s) Absent: Keith Diekmann, Phil Mahowald, Becky Sandahl
City staff members attending: Community Development Director Tim Benetti, Planner Alex
Sharpe, City Attorney Sharon Hills, and Department Assistant
Breanna Vincent.
2. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Chair Kurtz asked if there were any changes to the agenda. – None.
MOTION: Commissioner Schindler moved, seconded by Commissioner Scanlan,
approving the agenda. Roll call vote: Ayes - 4 – Nays – 0.
3. CONSENT ITEMS
A. Approve the 2024 Planning Commission Regular Meeting Schedule
B. Approval of Minutes of November 15, 2023
MOTION: Commissioner Schindler moved, seconded by Commissioner Scanlan,
approving the 2024 Meeting Schedule and the minutes of November 15,
2023. Roll call vote: Ayes - 4 – Nays – 0.
4. PUBLIC HEARING
A. Wings Credit Union Ordinance Amendment to PD-290 Zone 3
Chair Kurtz opened the public hearing.
Planner Sharpe provided a brief presentation.
Commissioner Prewitt asked if the adjacent properties were part of the notification of this
public hearing and if the businesses that previously sought signage (Aspen Dental) and
were denied a part of the notification.
CITY OF APPLE VALLEY
Dakota County, Minnesota
Planning Commission Minutes
December 20, 2023
Page 2 of 4
Planner Sharpe stated that zoning amendments only require notifying the properties within
that subzone (zone 3). Regarding Aspen Dental, their logo made there be a lot of negative
space in their text box.
Commissioner Scanlan asked at what height would the sign be considered “readable”. He
said that it seemed that the sign did not need to be the 20’ requested.
Planner Sharpe said that there is not a best practice and largely depends on the community
of Apple Valley and what commissioners set as policy.
Commissioner Scanlan agreed and stated he understood what Wings was attempting to do
but is concerned about the height requested. He said 16’ seemed like a more reasonable
option.
Chair Kurtz said that 20’ seemed like overkill and even 16’ was too high.
Commissioner Schindler stated that 20’ was too high but that 16’ was acceptable.
Commissioner Prewitt stated that currently the sign is concealed by landscaping and
possibly will seem larger once the area is wide open.
The applicant, Tom Schuenke (Wings Vice President Administration & Facilities) was
present to provide additional information on the need for an ordinance amendment. Mr.
Schuenke stated that ideally, they would like to have the 80 sq. ft. so that they can have
some flexibility with the design.
Commissioner Scanlan pointed out that the elevation in the staff report and the elevation in
the presentation were not the same. The photo in the presentation shows the sign about
halfway up the evergreen adjacent to it whereas the staff report shows it as being almost the
same height. The scale appears to be off.
Planner Sharpe stated that is likely due to updated graphic material received. He also stated
that the berm seen in the elevation in the presentation would not be there.
Commissioner Schindler pointed out that the angle in the two photos is different so that
could also add to the scaling difference.
Chair Kurtz asked for a reminder on what is located beneath the digital portion of the side.
Mr. Schuenke stated that there is nothing below the reader board. It is just a blue panel on
one side and the other side has slats for airflow.
CITY OF APPLE VALLEY
Dakota County, Minnesota
Planning Commission Minutes
December 20, 2023
Page 3 of 4
Chair Kurtz opined that the Wings building is one of the tallest in Apple Valley and can be
seen from afar. The sign would not be seen from afar. When driving, the top of the sign
would likely not be visible as it is too high. Chair Kurtz asked if Wings would be in support
of a lower height.
Mr. Schuenke stated that they would be in support of a 16’ height if they were granted the
80 sq. ft.
Chair Kurtz asked CD Director Benetti if Wings would be able to keep the 80 sq. ft. even if
the height were lowered.
CD Director Benetti stated that the Commission has the right to offer any recommendation
to the City Council for final decision-making.
City Attorney Hills stated that the Commission needs to either approve or deny the
application as it is currently, though they can make a recommendation to the City Council
on an alternate height or square footage if they choose to do so.
MOTION: Commissioner Scanlan moved, seconded by Commissioner Schindler, to
recommend denial of a amendment to Chapter 155, Appendix F-Article 2 of the
Apple Valley City Code revising Section A2-5 (A)(6) to allow the installation of a
freestanding ground sign with a maximum height of 20’ and total sign area not to
exceed 80 sq. ft. Roll call vote: Ayes – 4 – Nays – 0.
MOTION: Commissioner Scanlan moved, seconded by Commissioner Prewitt, to recommend
approval of an amendment to Chapter 155, Appendix F-Article 2 of the Apple
Valley City Code revising Section A2-5 (A)(6) to allow the installation of a
freestanding ground sign with a maximum height of 14’ and total sign area not to
exceed 80 sq. ft. Roll call vote: Ayes – 4 – Nays – 0.
5. LAND USE
6. OTHER BUSINESS
A. Review of Upcoming Schedule and Other Updates
The next Planning Commission meeting is scheduled for Wednesday, January 3, 2024,
7:00 p.m. The next City Council meeting is Thursday, December 28, 2023, 7:00 p.m.