HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-02-07 Regular Meeting MinutesCITY OF APPLE VALLEY
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES
February 7, 2024
1. CALL TO ORDER
The City of Apple Valley Planning Commission Meeting was called to order by Vice Chair
Scanlan at 7:00 p.m.
Members Present: Paul Scanlan, David Schindler, Phil Mahowald, Becky Sandahl,
and Jeff Prewitt
Member(s) Absent: Jodi Kurtz
City staff members attending: Community Development Director Tim Benetti, City Planner
Kathy Bodmer, Planner Alex Sharpe, Assistant City Engineer Evan
Acosta, City Attorney Sharon Hills, and Department Assistant
Breanna Vincent.
2. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Vice Chair Scanlan asked if there were any changes to the agenda. – None.
MOTION: Commissioner Schindler moved, seconded by Commissioner Mahowald,
approving the agenda. Roll call vote: Ayes - 5 – Nays – 0.
3. CONSENT ITEMS
A. Approval of Minutes of January 17, 2024
MOTION: Commissioner Schindler moved, seconded by Commissioner Mahowald,
approving the minutes of January 17, 2024. Roll call vote: Ayes - 5 – Nays –
0.
4. PUBLIC HEARING
A. Les Schwab Tire Center
Vice Chair Scanlan opened the public hearing.
CD Director Benetti gave a brief presentation.
Commissioner Mahowald asked for clarification on the number of bays proposed.
CD Director Benetti stated that typically Les Schwab has several bays or garage doors on
their buildings but under our ordinance they could only have two. Their plans show one
CITY OF APPLE VALLEY
Dakota County, Minnesota
Planning Commission Minutes
February 7, 2024
Page 2 of 5
entrance bay, where cars will then queue up inside the building for service and then one
bay on the other side for exiting.
Commissioner Mahowald stated that the original plans do not seem to fit the aesthetic of
other buildings in this development and he would like to see more architectural elements
that could make it more aesthetically pleasing to fit in with the development.
CD Director Benetti agreed that this area already has great product and staff would like to
see that continue. This building will be a unique building for Les Schwab as most of their
buildings have multiple garage doors for access to each of the service bays. The benefit to
the two bay opening proposed is that it may minimize noise.
Commissioner Mahowald stated that the revised design with the addition of the windows is
better but has room for improvement.
CD Director Benetti pointed out that the design elements on the middle of the building
shown in the elevation drawings are not windows but rather a decorative screening.
Vice Chair Scanlan asked for more information on the drive entry points.
CD Director Benetti stated that English Avenue is a private driveway and staff has
explored either keeping the two access points off English or closing one and having the
access point be more towards the middle of the two that were shown on the site plan. Staff
is open to suggestions from the commission.
Vice Chair Scanlan said that would be consistent with what is typically done in commercial
properties and going from two access points to one would be appropriate. Vice Chair
Scanlan asked if there had been a discussion on the location and materials of the trash
container.
CD Director Benetti stated that staff would prefer to see the trash container match the
materials of the building and will work with the applicant, especially since it is located
towards the front. Staff anticipates that old tires will be stored inside the building until
disposal.
Vice Chair Scanlan asked if there was a secondary option for the location of the trash
enclosure that would be less intrusive.
CD Director Benetti stated that the site is limited by the drainage and utility easement and
cannot have any structural material above that easement and had to focus on the west side
of the lot. If there are other areas for the location of the enclosure, staff will work with the
applicant.
CITY OF APPLE VALLEY
Dakota County, Minnesota
Planning Commission Minutes
February 7, 2024
Page 3 of 5
Vice Chair Scanlan pointed out that the signage shown in their renderings does not comply
with our sign ordinance and that the applicant may want to keep that in mind during their
design process.
Commissioner Sandahl asked how traffic would work with the access being reduced to one
entry and exit point on English.
CD Director Benetti said that the access point would be larger to accommodate traffic
turning left or right out of the site and traffic traveling north or south bound on English to
access the site.
Commissioner Mahowald asked what the speed limit on English Avenue was.
CD Director Benetti stated it was likely 30 mph.
The applicant, Mark Rohweder (KLJ Engineering), provided a brief presentation.
Commissioner Mahowald pointed out that the building shown on the first slide was a great
example of being aesthetically pleasing with the large windows/glass with the glass awning
on the front of the building.
Vice Chair Scanlan asked if there were any photos of the faux window panels being
discussed.
Mr. Rohweder stated he did not have a close-up photo of the panels.
Vice Chair Scanlan said that he was not a fan of faux window designs and would prefer
real windows. He also stressed the importance of having a four-sided balance in the design
elements. Vice Chair Scanlan also said he would prefer the trash enclosure materials to go
with the building.
Commissioner Sandahl agreed with adding real windows.
With no further comments, Vice Chair Scanlan closed the public hearing.
It is the policy of the Planning Commission not to act on an item the same night as its
public hearing.
5. LAND USE
None
6. OTHER BUSINESS
CITY OF APPLE VALLEY
Dakota County, Minnesota
Planning Commission Minutes
February 7, 2024
Page 4 of 5
A. Orchard Place Multi-Family Sketch Plan
Planner Bodmer provided a brief presentation.
Commissioner Prewitt asked if this development would be the first 4-story apartment in
Apple Valley.
Planner Bodmer stated that there is Applewood Pointe senior co-op.
Commissioner Mahowald pointed out that this area was originally designed with retail in
mind and expressed concerns with how placing a multi-family housing development will
impair future and existing development in the area.
Planner Bodmer responded that in the retail market, rooftops demand energy and demand
for retail. Additional housing could be a benefit to the area but it needs to be properly
designed. High density housing is becoming more common within retail areas.
Commissioner Sandahl expressed concerns over patio hours at neighboring restaurants
and how that may impact residential development or require restrictions placed upon
existing businesses.
Vice Chair Scanlan said that it will take some work to make this development work in the
retail area. He believes it could benefit the trailway system if done correctly. Vice Chair
Scanlan asked if this development would be higher in elevation than the townhomes
currently to the west of this site.
Planner Bodmer stated that the elevation difference would be interesting to explore and
verify.
Vice Chair Scanlan asked if this development would be better suited for the north end of
the development.
Commissioner Schindler stated that his preference would be for this development to not
add any residential. He agreed with comments made by other commissioners. He
expressed concerns over the amenities being located on the trail side of the property and
how people may think they are public amenities.
The applicant, Chris Moe (HJ Development), was present for questions.
City Attorney Hills pointed out that this is a sketch plan and there is no formal application
for this project, so a full proposal/presentation is not necessary. There should be no
opinions as to whether they would approve or deny it.